Skip to main content

Moving to Signal is hard

because it's a social move, not a real technical one.

In my social circle, I use the following text exchanging technologies when it comes to small messages : 

  • SMS
  • WhatsApp
  • Signal
  • Email

These make up probably more than 90% of all my communications. For more geekier ones, like open source contributions and professional ones, add slack, matrix and IRC. I don't use any other protocols.

Most of my personal communications are done over WhatsApp : Family group, Sports for the kids groups. One group I'm not part of still uses FB messenger.

Over the years, I've tried hard to move off WhatsApp. The issue is that Signal doesn't offer anything besides privacy that would make people move from WhatsApp. You can create groups, send images etc. People do not understand or care about the privacy implications of using WA. The recent addition of the AI circle in WA didn't change a thing. WA is everywhere, everyone has it. Signal is not installed by default, people will need to install it.

I've been successful at using signal still when creating new groups for instance. If a new group is being created, I refuse WA, I explain why signal is so much better, I go on and create the group, I then add people and make them admin so they feel at home this as worked for :

  • Virtual table-top player's group
  • Work alumni group

 It also works with individual people, you reply faster on signal than anywhere else they'll use signal with you. This worked with the manager of the kindergarten I'm the head of, diverse pen and paper RPG gamers. It worked with my wife and bigger son. I sometime send Signal invites and sometimes it works. It's slow, but more people are using it.

I have tried to convince the people using WA at scale (kids sports group), but they are very happy that WA works better than SMS groups and as it works they are afraid of breaking a momentum by trying to push people to signal.

One, I'm not able to move of WA, is my family group. We got momentum 2 years ago when WA changed it's GCU. I created a group, invited most of the WA participants, but usage didn't come. Recently, with the advent of the AI button, one cousin starting using it. 

This sparked the want to try again to move, so I posted an invitation to the family group in the family group and people clicked the link and joined. Then it sparked a conversation on WA about which one was better. I'm now trying to keep the momentum and conversations on Signal. The plan here is that people will remember to use Signal because it's more active.

What's your strategy to move to people you like off WhatsApp to Signal? 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Firefox OS's story from a mozilla insider not working on the project

  I clearly remember, but can't date it. I was working for Mozilla messaging at the time ( momo ), being the QA lead for Thunderbird. It was at the end of one of the Mozilla All-hands, maybe in 2011 or 2012. At one of the ending keynotes, we were introduced to Boot 2 Gecko. A hack that would let US - Mozilla own the platform to run a mobile browser on. At the time, the iPhone was going strong and Google was trying to catch up with Android. MeeGo had been in development at Nokia for a while but was going nowhere even when Intel tried to help. Blackberry was slowly starting to die. In the Silicon Valley everything was about mobile, mobile, mobile and the emerging South Easter Asian market, where people would skip computers and use smartphones to join the internet revolution. We were struggling with Chrome and the massive investment by Google to take market share. Our Firefox port on Android was having loads of issues. We were denied by Apple's policies to be present on iPhones....
3 comments
Read more

Key signing party at fosdem 2024

I'm organizing a GnuPG key signing party in order to bolster our web of trust , since there is no official ksp this year. I have organized a few in the past using tools like biglumber (website is gone, if someone know of a replacement or where the source code of site is, I might end up running one again) and others tools . I've also run once the KSP at FOSDEM and helped running it a few other times.    === Details below === When, Where   We'll meet in front of the infodesk stand in building K around 12:00 Sunday Feb 4th 2024. I'll have a sing of some sort with KSP and or Key Signing Party . Once enough participants show up we will move outside to proceed with the party. What to Bring Warm cloths as the party will happen outside this year, like in the good old days. I hope it won't rain, but it might. Piece of papers with your fingerprint written on them. Each piece should look like below:  $ gpg --fingerprint 34246C61F792FBCC1F23BFF296BD1F38FEA32B4D pub ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Gandi , je suis énervé, la partie email

 En mai dernier j'avais migré le service de messagerie de mon domaine depuis google (offre historique datant de 2006) gratuite vers le service de Gandi. J'avais les contraintes suivantes : un peu d'espace, on passait de 15GB/utilisateurs tentative de reprise de l'historique Neuf utilisateurs calendrier+ carnet d'adresse du webmail pop/imap/smtp avec du TLS dedans Ayant un domaine historique, j'avais droit à cinq boites gratuites. Mais, je devais m'acquitter du service supplémentaire jusqu'à la prochaine échéance de renouvellement du domaine, soit 2025. Avec des boites mail à 3Gb, cela faisait une facture de 400€. Avec les dernières annonces de Gandi, à partir de la fin d'année, il me faudrait débourser en sus 25€/mois pour garder un service équivalent et à partir de 2025 45€/mois. La très mauvaise surprise du mercredi. J'ai donc commencé à chercher des alternatives, sachant qu'à terme, j'aurais au moins deux utilisateurs de plus. Point p...
2 comments
Read more